CrimeTrakr Home
🔍
CrimeTrakr Rookie Member Badge

The Case of Brittany Tavar

Brittany Tavar, 45, was murdered in July 2010 by Joseph Dean Roberts, a transient man she had allowed to stay at her home in Ponte Vedra Beach, Florida. Following an argument connected to a DVD she had prepared for a legal dispute, Roberts beat Brittany with a hammer and subsequently disposed of her body in a wooded area. After the murder, Roberts took Brittany's vehicle, credit cards and other belongings and fled across the United States. Brittany was reported missing on 8 July 2010 after friends and family became concerned about her disappearance. Roberts was eventually arrested in Seattle, Washington, in October 2010 after being apprehended for shoplifting. During questioning, Roberts confessed to killing Brittany and provided investigators with information leading to the discovery of her remains. He pleaded guilty to second-degree murder in May 2014 and was sentenced to 30 years in prison.

The Case of Brittany Tavar
Offender
Joe Roberts
📁Case Overview
case_name:
The Case of Brittany Tavar
date:
6 July 2010
incident_place:
status:
killer_name:
⚖️Offender
full_name:
Joseph Dean Roberts
sex:
male_killer
sexual_orientation:
unknown
nationality:
american
status:
imprisoned

Overview / Background

Brittany Jenevieve Tavar was 45 years old and lived in the Ponte Vedra Beach area of St. Johns County, Florida. She was described by family and friends as generous, loving, thoughtful and kind. She had been involved in a civil dispute with a neighbour and had prepared a DVD containing footage she believed would assist her in the matter. Joseph Dean Roberts was a transient man who had been living with Brittany. She had offered him accommodation and assistance after he had experienced homelessness. The two became involved in a disagreement over the DVD and the legal matter Brittany was involved in. Roberts later admitted that the argument escalated and that he killed her.

Crime Scene

Brittany was last known to have been seen on 6 July 2010. Following her disappearance, investigators discovered that Roberts had taken her Toyota RAV4 and was travelling across the country. On 14 October 2010, investigators located human remains in a wooded area off State Road 207 near Lightsey Road in St. Johns County, Florida. The remains were found inside plastic bags and were in an advanced state of decomposition. Dental records were used to identify the remains as Brittany Tavar. The medical examiner determined that Brittany had died as a result of homicide, with blunt-force trauma identified as the cause of death. According to Roberts' confession, he had struck Brittany repeatedly with a hammer. He subsequently used a knife and disposed of her body in the wooded area.

Investigation

Brittany was reported missing on 8 July 2010 after friends and family became concerned when they were unable to contact her. Investigators quickly identified Joseph Dean Roberts as a person of interest. He had been seen with Brittany around the time of her disappearance and was subsequently found driving her Toyota RAV4 in Wyoming. At the time, she had not yet been formally reported missing. Authorities issued a nationwide search for Roberts. Brittany's dogs were also found in South Carolina after being located by members of the public and taken to a veterinarian, where microchip information identified their owner. Roberts continued travelling across the United States. Investigators tracked his movements through vehicle sightings, surveillance footage, credit-card transactions and other evidence. He was arrested in Seattle, Washington, in October 2010 after being apprehended in connection with a shoplifting incident. A computer check revealed outstanding warrants connected to Brittany's disappearance and the theft of her vehicle. St. Johns County detectives travelled to Washington to interview Roberts. During questioning, he confessed to killing Brittany and described the argument that preceded the murder. He also provided investigators with directions and a map leading to the location where he had disposed of her body. Investigators subsequently located the remains in the wooded area off State Road 207. Brittany was positively identified through dental records.

Outcome

Joseph Dean Roberts was initially charged with first-degree murder. The case experienced lengthy delays involving changes in legal representation and disputes concerning the admissibility of his confession and other evidence. On 2 May 2014, Roberts pleaded guilty to second-degree murder as part of a plea agreement. He was sentenced to 30 years' imprisonment for Brittany's murder. He also received a separate five-year prison sentence for a battery committed against another inmate while incarcerated. The additional sentence was imposed consecutively. The plea agreement resulted in other charges being dropped, including charges relating to the theft of Brittany's vehicle and witness-related offences. Roberts remains incarcerated in Florida.

Notes

Roberts described Brittany as someone who had helped him and admitted during his recorded confession that he had killed the person who was trying to assist him. Brittany's former boyfriend, Derryl Brown, spoke publicly about the loss and expressed anger over the sentence, stating that he believed Roberts should never be released from prison. The case attracted attention because Brittany had offered Roberts accommodation and assistance before he killed her, and because Roberts travelled across the country after the murder while using her vehicle and financial accounts.

Other Information

Roberts' confession helped investigators locate Brittany's remains after she had been missing for approximately three months.

The case was later featured in television true-crime programmes, including coverage examining Roberts' confession, his flight across the country and the investigation into Brittany's disappearance.


Sources

  • News4JAX - Confession details 2010 killing of Ponte Vedra Beach woman
  • News4JAX - Charge added in St. Johns County murder case
  • Historic City News - Joseph Roberts now in St Johns County jail
  • Historic City News - Positive ID of victim at gruesome crime scene
  • St. Augustine Record - Joseph Dean Roberts pleads guilty to murder
DashboardKillersVideosCasesBooks