Lesson 1: Why Do People Offend?
Explore the different factors researchers consider when trying to understand criminal behaviour.
๐ฌ The Big Question
When someone commits a crime, one question usually comes first:
Why did they do it?
It might seem like there should be a simple answer.
Maybe they wanted money.
Maybe they were angry.
Maybe they wanted control.
Maybe they saw an opportunity.
But criminologists know that criminal behaviour is rarely explained by one factor alone.
Instead, they look at the different influences that may have come together before, during or around an offence.
[[cinematic scene image: A moody but non-graphic crime scene outside a suburban house, police officers investigating while the surrounding environment and circumstances are visible]]
๐จ Crime Has Many Pieces
When researchers try to understand offending, they may consider factors involving the:
Factor | What might be considered? |
|---|---|
๐งฌ Individual | Personality, behaviour, attitudes and decision-making |
๐ถ Development | Childhood, development and life experiences |
๐ฅ Relationships | Family, friends, partners and peer influence |
๐๏ธ Environment | Neighbourhood, community and social surroundings |
๐ฐ Social & economic | Education, employment, disadvantage and instability |
๐ช Situation | Opportunity, access and circumstances |
๐ฏ Motivation | What the person may want to achieve |
None of these factors automatically makes someone a criminal.
They are pieces of a much bigger puzzle.
๐ ROOKIE TIP
A risk factor is not a prediction.
A risk factor is something associated with an increased likelihood of a particular outcome.
Someone can experience several recognised risk factors and never commit a crime.
๐งฌ Nature, Nurture & Experience
You've probably heard the phrase:
Nature vs nurture.
It's the old question of whether our behaviour is influenced more by what we're born with or by the environment in which we grow up.
The reality is much more complicated.
Genetics, development, upbringing, relationships and life experiences can all interact in different ways.
[[presentation slide: Nature and nurture shown as overlapping influences on behaviour, with genetics, upbringing, development and life experiences around the central concept of behaviour]]
There is no single โcriminal geneโ that determines whether someone will offend.
A person's biology or background may be part of the picture, but it doesn't come with a label saying future criminal.
โ ๏ธ REMEMBER
Influence isn't destiny.
A factor can influence behaviour without determining it.
๐ช Opportunity Matters
Sometimes the circumstances surrounding a crime can be just as interesting as the person committing it.
Imagine two cars:
๐ Car A: Locked, alarm active and parked in a secure area.
๐ Car B: Unlocked, keys visible and parked somewhere isolated.
The opportunity is very different.
That doesn't mean everyone who sees Car B will steal it.
It simply shows why criminologists also study situations and environments, not just the people involved.
An opportunity is a situation that makes a particular action possible or easier to carry out.
๐ LOOK CLOSER
Sometimes the question isn't just:
โWho would commit this crime?โ
It's also:
โWhat made this crime possible?โ
๐ฏ Motive Is Only One Piece
A motive is the reason someone may want to do something.
Criminal motives can vary enormously.
A person might be motivated by:

But identifying a motive doesn't necessarily explain the whole offence.
A criminologist might therefore ask:
What influenced this person? โข What circumstances were present? โข What opportunity existed? โข What decisions did they make?
These questions help move us beyond the assumption that every crime has one obvious explanation.
โ๏ธ Understanding Isn't Excusing
This distinction is important.
Criminologists study offending because they want to understand how and why it happens.
That doesn't mean they believe the behaviour was acceptable.
Understanding the factors involved can help researchers identify patterns, develop prevention strategies and better understand criminal behaviour.
โ ๏ธ REMEMBER
Understanding why โ excusing what happened.
Explaining behaviour and justifying behaviour are two completely different things.
๐ง Think About It
Imagine two people who grow up in very similar circumstances.
Both experience financial hardship.
Both have unstable family lives.
Both associate with people involved in crime.
One eventually becomes involved in serious offending.
The other doesn't.
What might explain the different outcomes?
Think about your answer before revealing the explanation.
๐งฉ Rookie Recruit Takeaway
Crime rarely has a single cause.
Understanding criminal behaviour means looking beyond the offence itself and considering the person, their development, relationships, environment, circumstances, motivations and opportunities surrounding it.
The important lesson?
There isn't a simple formula for criminal behaviour.
Coming Up Next โก๏ธ
We've established that criminal behaviour can have many influences.
Now we're going to look more closely at one of the biggest questions in criminology:
Nextup:
Nature, Nurture & Development ...
โ Answer.
The circumstances may be similar, but people respond to them differently. Individual characteristics, relationships, choices, experiences, opportunities and other influences can all interact. Similar risk factors do not guarantee similar outcomes.













