Chase Merritt: CA, McStay Family Murderer

The disappearance of the McStay family in 2010 gripped California and soon the entire world. When the bodies of Joseph, Summer, and their two young sons were discovered buried in shallow graves in the Mojave Desert nearly four years later, the horror deepened. At the center of this case stood Charles “Chase” Merritt, a man once trusted as Joseph’s business partner and friend. Their close relationship, built through their shared venture in decorative water features, was torn apart by financial deceit, greed, and desperation. Merritt’s betrayal revealed a chilling portrait of a man who turned lethal when his livelihood was at risk.

Investigators quickly noted inconsistencies in Merritt’s story after the McStay family vanished on February 4, 2010. He admitted to being the last person to see Joseph alive, but phone records, financial trails, and erratic behavior soon painted a darker picture. Evidence showed Merritt writing checks to himself from Joseph’s business account days after the family disappeared and checks forged with Joseph’s name. When the McStay family’s remains were found in 2013, the discovery of a sledgehammer near the graves would later become a key piece of physical evidence linking Merritt to the crime.

Do you think the police caught on to him too late?x

“I loved Joseph. I would never hurt him.”
~ Chase Merritt

The prosecution built its case around motive and greed. Merritt, heavily in debt and gambling frequently, was desperate for cash. They alleged that when Joseph confronted him about missing funds, Merritt snapped by killing the entire family to cover his tracks. The brutality of the crime shocked even seasoned investigators. Each family member suffered repeated blows to the head, indicating a rage that extended beyond self-preservation. Detectives believed that once Merritt killed Joseph, he chose to eliminate every witness including two innocent children in a calculated effort to erase his betrayal.

How could someone carry such hate for friends and children alike?x

The trial, which began in 2019, lasted months and included over 150 witnesses. Merritt acted out in court, firing and rehiring attorneys multiple times, and even requesting to represent himself at one stage with actions that some viewed as manipulation or arrogance. Ultimately, the jury deliberated for just a few days before convicting him on four counts of first-degree murder. In 2020, Merritt was sentenced to death, marking a dramatic end to nearly a decade of speculation surrounding the McStay case.

Would you have reached the same verdict as the jury?x

“They’ve got this wrong, I am innocent.”
~ Chase Merritt

The emotional weight of the case was immense. Joseph’s and Summer’s extended families spoke of the unbearable loss and the void left by the deaths of the two boys. The McStay home had shown no signs of forced entry, leading police to initially suspect voluntary disappearance or abduction. But as the evidence came together, it revealed something even darker with betrayal by someone from within their trusted circle. The discovery in the desert turned suspicion into certainty: they hadn’t walked away from their lives, they had been brutally taken.

Today, Charles “Chase” Merritt remains on death row in San Quentin State Prison. He continues to maintain his innocence, despite overwhelming forensic and circumstantial evidence. His case stands as one of the most chilling examples of how greed and betrayal can unravel into murder. For many, it serves as a grim reminder that evil doesn’t always come from strangers but sometimes, it comes from those closest to us.

Photo: CBS News

Media: